Butterfinger Bites Recipe – Cheez‑It & Chocolate Peanut Butter Treats

1. Introduction to the Recipe

Imagine a snack that delivers the salty crunch of Cheez‑Its, the creamy richness of peanut butter, and the indulgent sweetness of semi‑sweet chocolate—all in one bite‑sized treat. That’s the magic behind Butterfinger Bites, a no‑bake dessert that’s as fun to make as it is to eat. Perfect for impromptu gatherings, after‑school snacks, or mid‑afternoon pick‑me‑ups, this recipe combines pantry staples into something unexpectedly decadent.

The appeal of these Butterfinger Bites lies in their simplicity and versatility. With just Cheez‑Its for structure, creamy peanut butter to bind, and melted semi‑sweet chocolate enhanced with a touch of oil for the perfect sheen, you can create a snack that satisfies sweet‑and‑savory cravings in just minutes. If you’re intrigued by no‑bake chocolate treats, you may also enjoy classic recipes like chocolate peanut butter no‑bake cookies or want to brush up on best techniques for melting chocolate evenly.

So whether you’re looking to whip up something quick for a party or want to surprise loved ones with a fun homemade candy, these Butterfinger Bites are a true winner. The combination of crunchy Cheez‑Its and smooth chocolate‑peanut‑butter coating creates a contrast of textures and flavors that’s irresistible. Let’s dive into how to make them, then explore advanced tweaks, storage tips, dietary adaptations, FAQs, and final thoughts.

---

2. Basic Recipe: Ingredients and Instructions

Print

---

3. Advanced Techniques

1. Tempering Chocolate for a Glossy, Crisp Finish

Tempering your chocolate creates stable cocoa crystals, resulting in a sheen and snap that stays crisp even at room temperature. To do this, melt two‑thirds of your semi‑sweet chocolate chips over low heat (or in the microwave in 20‑second bursts). Remove from heat, then stir in the remaining one‑third of unmelted chocolate to cool the mixture. Continue stirring until fully smooth and glossy. Use immediately to coat your peanut‑butter‑Cheez‑It sandwiches. This method yields a professional-looking finish and ensures the chocolate won’t bloom (develop white streaks) over time—even when stored at warm room temperatures.

2. Double‑Dip Technique for Thicker Chocolate Layers

If thicker chocolate coating is your goal, consider a double‑dip method. First, conduct a thin coating by dipping each sandwich and allowing it to set briefly. Once the first layer has partially hardened, dip again to build up the thickness, then let fully set. The result is a more indulgent bite, and the layered approach helps prevent overwhelming the Cheez‑It crunch with too much chocolate at once. Be sure both the first layer and the second layer have enough time to set; you can chill between dips to speed this.

3. Flavor Infusion by Adding Extracts or Zest

Elevate the flavor profile by subtly infusing the chocolate with complementary flavors. For example, whisk in ½ teaspoon of vanilla extract, orange zest, or even a pinch of sea salt when the chocolate is still warm and fluid. The extracts should be oil‑based or added sparingly to avoid seizing the chocolate. Zest works particularly well with orange chocolate, echoing the peanut butter’s nuttiness while adding brightness. A pinch of flaky sea salt on top of the wet chocolate before it sets can also add a sophisticated salty‑sweet contrast that plays off the Cheez‑Its beautifully.

4. Use of Crunch Enhancements for Textural Contrast

For extra crunch in every bite, sprinkle chopped peanuts, toffee bits, or crushed toffee on top of each coated sandwich immediately after dipping (while chocolate is still wet). The result is a layered texture: the crunch of Cheez‑Its, the smoothness of peanut butter, the firmness of chocolate, and a final crisp from the topping. It adds visual flair and extra flavor without much effort. To avoid sliding, gently press the embellishments into the surface of the chocolate coating. Let fully set before handling.

5. Temperature Control to Prevent Bloom and Preserve Gloss

Stay mindful of ambient temperature when working with chocolate. Chocolate is sensitive to heat and humidity—if your kitchen is above ~75°F (24°C), it may take longer to set and risk developing bloom. Use a cool, dry work surface, and store assembled bites in the coolest part of your home for setting. If necessary, rotate the tray in the fridge or freezer (long enough to firm but not so long as to cause condensation when removing). This care not only preserves the beautiful appearance of the chocolate but prevents texture degradation and keeps your Butterfinger Bites looking and tasting their best.

See more advanced recipes at cookingwhite.com

---

4. Storage, Shelf Life, and Maintenance Tips

1. Room‑Temperature Storage for Immediate Serving

If you plan to enjoy your Butterfinger Bites within a day or two, storing them at room temperature works well—just be sure to keep them in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight or heat sources. Place them in a single layer in an airtight container to prevent the chocolate coating from sweating or becoming sticky. Under ideal conditions (around 68–72°F or 20–22°C), they’ll remain crisp and fresh for up to 2–3 days without refrigeration. Anything beyond that, and the peanut butter’s oils may begin to migrate, softening the Cheez‑Its.

2. Refrigerator Storage for Extended Freshness

To prolong shelf life to 5–7 days, refrigerate your Butterfinger Bites in an airtight container. Line the container with parchment to prevent sticking, and consider layering bites with parchment or wax paper in between. Chilling maintains the firmness of the chocolate and slows the natural softening of the Cheez‑Its. When you’re ready to serve, let them sit at room temperature for about 10–15 minutes so the chocolate’s shine returns and they’re not too cold to bite into easily.

3. Freezing for Long‑Term Storage

For weeks or even up to a month of storage, the freezer is your friend. Arrange the Butterfinger Bites in a single layer on a tray and freeze until firm, then transfer to a freezer‑safe, airtight container or resealable bag, separating layers with parchment. When you want to enjoy them, simply move them to the refrigerator for about 20 minutes, then to room temperature briefly before serving to preserve texture and taste. Properly sealed, these treats maintain quality well and thaw with little change in flavor or texture.

4. Protecting Against Moisture and Sweating

Chocolate-coated treats are prone to “sweating” if exposed to moisture or drastic temperature changes. To avoid this, ensure that when moving from cold storage (fridge or freezer) to room temperature, you let the bites transition slowly. Don’t place them directly on a warm counter—leave the container closed and let condensation happen inside before opening. Wipe off any excess moisture inside your container before placing fresh treats inside, and always use dry utensils when handling.

5. Reviving Soft or Soggy Bites

If the Cheez‑Its soften or the coating loses its crispness due to plum optional storage issues, you can revive them: Preheat your oven to a low 250°F (120°C). Place the bites on a parchment‑lined baking sheet and warm them for 3–5 minutes—watch closely so the chocolate doesn’t melt fully. The gentle heat helps re‑crisp the crackers and re‑firm the coating. Let cool completely before serving. Use this trick sparingly to preserve fresh flavor—overheating may cause the peanut butter to become oily or the chocolate to bloom.

---

5. Dietary Adaptations and Substitutions

1. Vegan Version

For a vegan adaptation of Butterfinger Bites, swap the creamy peanut butter for a plant‑based alternative (check labels to ensure no whey). Replace the semi‑sweet chocolate chips with vegan chocolate chips made without milk solids, and use refined coconut oil (if avoiding coconut’s flavor) or another neutral plant oil. Choose vegan Cheez‑Its alternatives or crisp tortilla‑like crackers for the “sandwich” base—some brands offer vegan cheese crackers. By ensuring each component is vegan, you’ll maintain the salty‑sweet interplay, though the flavor will shift depending on the replacements.

2. Gluten‑Free Option

To accommodate a gluten‑free diet, substitute the Cheez‑Its with certified gluten‑free cheddar crackers or other crunchy gluten‑free cheese‑flavored crackers. Be sure to read labels carefully, as cross‑contamination is possible. The rest of the recipe—peanut butter, semi‑sweet chocolate, and oil—are naturally gluten‑free, but always choose brands labeled gluten‑free to be safe. This swap preserves the texture and structure of your Butterfinger Bites while making them accessible to those avoiding gluten.

3. Nut‑Free Alternative

For nut‑free dietary needs, swap creamy peanut butter with a safe seed butter such as sunflower‑seed butter or soy nut butter (ensure the brand hasn’t been processed on shared lines with peanuts if allergies are severe). For the flavor contrast, you could add a hint of maple syrup or vanilla to compensate for the missing nuttiness. The chocolate coating remains the same, though double‑check for traces of nut allergens. This adaptation keeps the creamy binder effect but is allergy‑friendly and still delectably sweet.

4. Lower‑Sugar Adaptation

If you’re leaning toward lower‑sugar indulgence, try using dark chocolate chips with at least 70% cacao and reduced‑sugar peanut butter (or make your own with peanuts and minimal sweetener). You can also use unsweetened cocoa with a sugar substitute like erythritol-based sweetener, and adjust consistency with a bit more oil to keep it melty enough to coat. For the Cheez‑It substitute, select a low‑sugar cheese cracker or crunchy roasted chickpeas for dipping instead. The resulting bites will be less sweet but still deliver satisfying flavor and texture.

5. Dairy‑Free Variation

To make Butterfinger Bites dairy‑free, choose a dairy‑free semi‑sweet or dark chocolate labeled vegan (many dark chocolates are already dairy‑free, but always check for milk fat or whey). For the Cheez‑It base, use dairy‑free cheese crackers—or even skip the cheese flavor and use crispy salt‑and‑vinegar or savory rice crackers. Pair with your favorite dairy‑free creamy spread—sunflower‑seed butter, tahini, or a coconut‑based spread. Although the cheese‑cracker base flavor changes, the crunchy‑chocolate experience remains delicious and suitable for those avoiding dairy.

---

6. FAQs About the Recipe

1. Can I substitute Cheez‑Its with another cracker?

Absolutely! If you’d like to substitute the Cheez‑Its, opt for crackers that are thin, crisp, and sturdy—like saltines, Ritz, or other savory snack crackers. Just remember, the flavor profile will shift: saltines will be more neutral, Ritz slightly buttery, etc. Choose crackers that aren’t overly thick, so the peanut butter and chocolate aren’t overwhelmed. In a pinch, even pretzel squares or rice crackers could work. Always test one or two to ensure they hold up through dipping and setting.

2. Why did my chocolate coating turn grainy or seize?

Seizing often happens when chocolate gets too hot or contact with even a drop of water occurs. To avoid graininess, melt your chocolate gently—use short microwave bursts (like 20 seconds), stirring well each time. If you notice any small lumps or the chocolate becomes thick, you can add a tiny bit of oil or non-dairy creamer—only about ½ teaspoon at a time—to smooth it out. Avoid steam around your melting bowl, and don’t allow any moisture to enter.

3. My Cheez‑Its slipped apart after coating—what went wrong?

This usually means the peanut butter layer was too thin or the chocolate wasn’t set quickly enough. To fix this, ensure each Cheez‑It sandwich has enough peanut butter (about ½ teaspoon) to act as glue. You can also chill the assembled sandwiches before dipping so they’re firmer. Lastly, work quickly and let the chocolate set in a cool spot or the refrigerator—this “locks” everything in before the peanut butter shifts.

4. Can I make these ahead for a party?

Yes, Butterfinger Bites are great for advance prep. You can assemble the sandwiches, chill them, and coat up to one day ahead. Store in a single layer in an airtight container in the fridge, then let them sit at room temperature for 10–15 minutes before serving to regain some gloss and texture. If you need more time, freeze them (see the freezing tips above), then thaw in the fridge the day before the event.

5. My bites are melting or sweating too much—how do I fix that?

This typically means they’re been exposed to heat or humidity. Keep them in the coolest part of your fridge and serve from a cool container. If they’re sweating, let them acclimate slowly—keep them in a closed container when bringing them from fridge to room temperature, then open when condensation subsides. For warm gatherings, consider serving on a chilled platter or over ice to prolong structure. Also, tempering your chocolate can help it resist melting for longer.

---

7. Conclusion & Final Thoughts

The beauty of Butterfinger Bites lies in their effortless glamour and irresistible flavor fusion. Crunchy Cheez‑Its, creamy peanut butter, and glossy semi‑sweet chocolate come together into bite‑sized perfection—each component balancing sweet, salty, smooth, and crisp in a way that elevates simple pantry staples into a memorable treat.

Why make these Butterfinger Bites? Because they’re fast: with minimal prep and no baking required, they’re ideal for last‑minute get‑togethers or satisfying sudden snack cravings. They’re fun: assembling, dipping, and setting is almost therapeutic (and kid‑friendly too). And they’re versatile: through the advanced techniques you can fancy them with double dips and flavors, and with the adaptations you can cater to vegans, gluten‑free guests, nut‑free needs, or those watching sugar.

Whether you’re preparing a treat for movie night, gifting batch‑made bites to friends, or just indulging in a personal sweet craving, these Butterfinger Bites offer a no‑fuss, high‑impact dessert option. Don’t underestimate the power of combining everyday ingredients in a delightful format—the crunch, the coating, and the creamy center are surprisingly satisfying together.

At the heart of this recipe is the pleasure of contrast—the crunchy Cheez‑Its, smooth peanut butter, and silky chocolate. Paired with your favorite beverage—coffee, tea, or a cold glass of milk—they create an elevated snack experience. And because the recipe is easily adaptable and forgiving, it invites creativity and experimentation.

So go ahead: make Butterfinger Bites, share them, store them (if they last that long), experiment with flavors, and enjoy every satisfying crunch. You’ll find they become a go‑to recipe for quick satisfaction, festive fun, or creative snacking. Indulgent yet accessible, bold yet simple—these little bites punch well above their weight and are destined to become a favorite whenever you need something sweet, salty, and supremely snackable.